13 Comments
Nov 9, 2021Liked by Mathew Crawford

The jury room is about the only place where your vote matters. One vote can save an innocent man from going to prison. The jury is the last and only reliable bulwark against tyranny.

I never made it through all of the TAOCP volumes. But it is mind expanding.

Expand full comment
Nov 9, 2021Liked by Mathew Crawford

Agreed, this was an excellent paper. Ran into from other sources a while ago. Looking forward to your thoughts/expansion!

Expand full comment
Nov 9, 2021Liked by Mathew Crawford

I've done multiple presentations about the types of censoring and imputation methods involved in clinical trials and public health data. Ignorable missing (MCAR and MAR) have statistical methods(MI, FCS, MCMC, or EM) to cope with this type data and it is acceptable to approximate . When you have informative missing/censoring (NMAR) there is no optimal method to fix the issue. ALL METHODS LEAD TO BIAS ESTIMATORS ,even multiple imputation will not be successful. The best you can do is sensitivity analysis by using the extremes to impute and come up with a wide rage of possibilities.

Expand full comment

While there is never a good time to serve, you have to take the opportunity when it arises because there is nothing better you can do with your time as a citizen of this country. Oddly, I am a lawyer but have had the good fortune to serve as a juror twice. Once before and once after the JD. The first case was an accident that was clearly trumped up injuries. We awarded the child a small sum for being used and gave the adult plaintiff nothing. The jury felt very righteous. On the second, a criminal trial, of course I was made foreman and then hung it in favor of the defendant. Quite the experience both times and I highly recommend it. I am probably one of a very few people who have played every role: prosecutor/plaintiff’s lawyer, defense, judge, juror, expert witness and mediator in both civil and criminal. I can tell you that if I were charged with a crime I would waive my right to a jury trial without hesitation. Especially after also teaching college for a time. The grand jury is another matter entirely.

Expand full comment
Nov 9, 2021Liked by Mathew Crawford

Cross your fingers for a grand jury. A runaway grand jury can theoretically accomplish *anything.*

Expand full comment

Being on a jury is one of the most patriotic things you can do. I've been on 2 and enjoyed both. Be aware of jury nullification and inform your fellow jurors (if the case warrants it), the lawyers aren't allowed to bring the subject up but it is entirely in your Constitutional right to do so. Also volunteer to be the foreman, they'll listen to you more if you are (and you'll be the smartest one out of the 12, so they need to be listening to you).

Expand full comment

Reeder's paper was excellent and very approachable. unfortunately, the biases he proposes will never be addressed by the study authors or anyone pumping the narrative. i'm really looking forward to seeing how informative censoring models can be applied to finance. i can see how summary statistics introduce bias to traditional time series analysis and risk metrics. the null vaccine concept seems like an important jump. hope you're back settled in your living arrangements soon.

Expand full comment