Since then, we have understood what is going on, and we found a guy in Arizona, who's been telling the HVE story to anyone (willing to listen) for many years:
I'm glad you found this article. I was going to email it to your team later, but have had a busy day so far.
I have half a book written that splits time between the important biases. I've struggled to focus due to the many topics important in the Big Picture. If you or anyone on your team is interested in the project, let me know. I'd love either a co-author, or just somebody new to hand off my cobbled together U.S. county/state database to.
Note that Dr. Shahar, your Brownstone reference, is Professor emeritus.
I have noticed this for the 4 1/2 years of the Covid plandemic - the only people who are able to publicly dispute or analyse "The Narrative" are independent of sanction for publicizing their information and conclusions. Cf. Robert Kennedy, Jr. and Steve Kirsch in the USA, both independently wealthy. Numerous victims in Canada such as Dr. Charles Hoffe and Dr. Mark Trozzi have been abused and sanctioned for proposing the truth as they experienced it.
In the "Climate Catastrophe" scam Dr. William Happer and his associates are similarly free of institutional suppression and worth reading.
Very sorry to hear of your continuing illness. Please do what you can to get plenty of sunshine to help yourself heal. God bless you and keep you from harm. Thank you for your work in the service of mankind. Amen.
Thanks. I have been inching nearer to 100%. Lately, I've made my second run this year at getting a consistent bed time in order. Last week it was a drag, but this week I'm getting to sleep between 8 PM and midnight (about to barely make it), and sleeping for 10 hours a day to catch up.
I haven't had anything affect my lungs much in a few months, except I have a slight wheeze from Spring pollen. Pseudafed does the trick.
It may simply be at this point that a year's worth of less exercise, and getting beat up, has my energy level at a lower baseline. But it's getting better.
I think the LED artificial pulsed lighting used at night is not good for you, especially during colder months we are more indoors. Up with the sun and down with the sun puts your body in a much better rhythm and strong state. Get incandescent to read at night.
I haven’t thought about this in 50 years but when I was a kid one of my school mates told me his great grandmother cured a bout of intestinal parasites by drinking turpentine. It allegedly worked! At the time we all got a good laugh from the story.
If you have a source on this product could you share? I'm interested in all of these old remedies they have used forever until modern medicine of course.
Yes, I am also sorry to hear that you have not fully recovered your health this year. Clean diet, exercise, restorative sleep, and plenty of fresh air and sunshine.
Great article! I, for one, have always thought vaccinations worked (though I never felt they should be forced). The manipulation of data, immunological omissions and sundry lies during covid have led me (and many others) to seriously question the truthfulness of anything vaccine/drug related. The magnitude of increasingly obvious lies during covid leads me to be significantly more wary of any claims that have been made regarding any vaccine. That doesn't mean vaccines are inherently ineffective or bad but it certainly doesn't mean they arent. And how can we really know when truthful scientific analysis, discussion and constant reevaluation are tantamount to heresy?
I suspect that at least a wide swath of vaccines are just playing pretend, and the authorities know that the data is too difficult to tease apart when you give half a dozen to child at a time. It's criminal.
I never questioned vaccines. Why would I? Each generation since before my grandparents were living longer, infant and child mortality had improved significantly. It sure seemed like the story they were telling made sense.
Seems like pushback started brewing in earnest in the mid 1990s. Stunningly it was the liberals in entertainment and coastal cities that were complaining while conservatives waved them off as whackos.
Given events of late that is some crazy irony, no?
It didn’t hit me until around 2017 they fired high ranking doctor Daniel Neides at the Cleveland Clinic where I worked.
His infraction was merely suggesting we might be better served by questioning the link between autism and childhood vaccinations.
The shitstorm at work and in the media was off the charts. It was insane. Personally I found the reaction highly suspicious.
Here’s the thing as I see it, medicine is a branch of science and science should always be allowed to question. Otherwise what you’ve got ain’t science. It is politics.
Science is by its very nature mercurial. Ever-learning thus changing, adapting and evolving.
Whether I agreed with Dr. Neides questioning of a possible causal link or not was immaterial. Let’s check it out. Let’s do science! But, no.
Shutting him down with major ridicule and loss of employment was over the top. Thus as a result I became way more skeptical of vaccines. And, now? Since Covid. I don’t trust any of them anymore.
Even if the shots were safe as saline and had zero side effects there is enough empirical evidence to show they do not function as advertised.
Yet from where I sit the Covidians remain stubbornly steadfast in their resolve. This is unsurprising to anyone that possesses a basic understanding of human psychology.
Once people openly commit that Coke is better than Pepsi precious few will backtrack. That is why society was panic bludgeoned from the get-go.
It was important to cement vaccine logic into the collective consciousness hard and fast. So they used fear over a phantom menace to do it.
Now, four years later we are stuck with the aftermath. People refusing to see the depth and breadth of a worldwide con. Those professing to see the con focus on personal harms but in reality several million mostly ignored harms and deaths are just a means to an end.
The con was meant to forever change the way we see reality. It shattered Nuremberg, informed consent, personal sovereignty, all rights, bodily, parental, religious, economic, social,personal property. It changed how we perceive government, military and corporate authority.
The con plastered over everything we took for granted and paved the way for the acceptance of authoritarian rule.
The acceptance of authoritarian rule is what Covid was (and still is) all about, Charlie Brown.
Thank you for the final section about making it more simple. I appreciate your work and marvel at the mathematical complexity in your analyses. I am a veterinarian and not a mathematician so I do tend to get lost at times. But, I keep reading!
Sometimes there is no crisis without a reaction. Sometimes the whole town is burning. The real events make the fake events feel scarier because it takes some time to know the difference when the news cycle starts up.
Thanks, Mathew. The clown show was indeed the agenda of the oligarchy. I was fortunate to have begun a deep dive into the history of vaccination and Rockefeller medicine at least a decade before 2020, and having long been a New Yorker subscriber, whose increasingly frequent articles about pandemics and other heebie-jeebies alerted me that something was up, I smelled a psy-op right at the beginning. Helps to be naturally skeptical, too, which, in my case, was thoroughly developed and reinforced through schooling. Mathematics is beautiful (except in California, where it is now woke); it doesn't lie.
We don't need any more studies. All vaccines are useless and harmful otherwise we'd be the healthiest country on the planet. After 70 years, we aren't even close.
I hold out the possibility that a subset of vaccines may be successful at the mucosal membrane. Of course, this is less likely for anything injected, and the inclusion of poisons as adjuvants is a big clue that this isn't for our benefit.
The reported finding of "Zero vaccine effectiveness" after looking at all-cause mortality, would tell me that at least these vaccines aren't bad either. However, many countries record excess mortality and are unwilling to share anonymised record-level data to allow people to find the cause of this excess mortality. Meanwhile large increases in cancer and heart-disease have been linked to the Covid-19 vaccines. As far as I understand this analysis, the title should be "Proof of shoddy data analysis by public bodies". Why make out that vaccine effectiveness is zero because very likely it's negative?
I've pondered this, and I think that after accounting for healthy user bias for vaccines, we must also account for increases in drug and alcohol deaths, which have an unhealthy user bias, and tilt back the other direction. I do think that my original calculations that I did in mid-2021 are still likely correct---particularly since they were spot on with the German health insurer's 400k interviews.
But conclusions are based on data that is itself nonsensical, as in showing that Covid-19 vaccine seems to help prevent traffic-accident deaths, for example. I think in the present circumstances, with a paucity of reliable data, it's too bold to state there is "Zero Vaccine Effectiveness". We don't know that yet, because likely there is Negative vaccine effectiveness. And that means it doesn't really make sense to look at all cause mortality and talk about vaccine effectiveness. We still don't know whether the vaccine prevented some Covid-19 illness which was offset by people dying from a heart attack due to vaccination.
I could say all this is fine and dandy, job well done, cudos, and any other commendation. In fact, it is piddling about, which also involves HUB, HVE, UVE, ZVEH, and all the other monstrous academic constructs. What good is it analyzing whether the poison death shot (TM@Dr. Zelenko, RIP) works or not, while maintaining the gross fiction of a "vaccine", or even "pandemic"? It is as if scholastics came back, with their multitude of angels dancing on the point of a needle.
As for Karl Rove, he must be rolling over with laughter on his sofa. "We’re an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you’re studying that reality — judiciously, as you will — we’ll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that’s how things will sort out. We’re history’s actors . . . and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do.” Indeed - studying, check; judiciously, check; you, all of you; really wanna be a part of the set that proves Rove right?
It is not about what the injectable poisonous LNP slops do not do; it is about what they do do, because by their fruits ye shall know them. The fruits are the same everywhere, and statistically if you wish, come in the shape of excess mortality. The current Protectorate of Boehmen u. Maehren recorded excess mortality of 7.5% in 2022, and 10.1% in 2023. Occam´s razor is the only thing that Mr. Furst need apply here. Morbidity and disability would be the other tracks to follow, together with ancillary data like waiting times for being seen by a neurologist (10 months) or psychiatrist (4 months). Just those two specialties would give some indication of what is up, and Slide 16 provides the reasons why.
"What good is it to write any article other than the one that I would have written talking about other things? Karl Rove knows that writing about anything is useless."
It was very interesting to see how intensely people embraced the idea that if you took the shot you were great and you did everything. If you didn't take it ,you were a granny killing piece of crap who did nothing .At no point did the idea get brought up that the best way to approach the mucosal immune system is through the nose and mouth, not an injection. Vitamin d levels, nasal sprays, zinc etc. were considered anti vaxx before the shots even came out. Many useful pieces of information emerged, When Hydroxy and ivermectin were cut off, people realized that quercetin could get the zinc into the cells. Vitamin d levels above 50nm seems to be the biggest key. I firmly believe that three pairings of nutrients should be promoted for optimal illness protection at minimal expense. 1-vitamin d3 and vitamin k2. 2-magnesium and vitamin c. 3-zinc and quercetin(or black seed oil). I take this combo every day and rarely catch anything. All of these are important and in combination they bring out the full potential of the vitamin d and zinc. That is the large study I would like to see. People taking proper amounts of those six nutrients every day vs. all the flu and covid shots.
Very interesting – county doctors vs city doctors. I agree it is the tricksters (large international corporations & evil ones) who are creating a toxic world (vaccines, other drugs, environment, and much more) but also their brainwashing and control of the media, government… is amazing.
Hello Mathew,
thank you very much for this post! If you ever come to Czech Republic, the beer is on us:)
The HVE is a really fascinating topic. We first noticed it here:
https://smis-lab.cz/2021/12/25/umrti-dle-ockovaciho-statutu-v-roce-2021-data-zdravotnich-pojistoven/
(sorry, it is in Czech but googletranslate does a decent job)
and you may witness our confusion then here:
https://smis-lab.cz/2022/01/07/elixir-mladi/
Since then, we have understood what is going on, and we found a guy in Arizona, who's been telling the HVE story to anyone (willing to listen) for many years:
https://brownstone.org/articles/healthy-vaccinee-bias-letter-to-editor-lancet-regional-health-europe/
Thank you again,
all the best
Tomas Fürst
Tomas,
I'm glad you found this article. I was going to email it to your team later, but have had a busy day so far.
I have half a book written that splits time between the important biases. I've struggled to focus due to the many topics important in the Big Picture. If you or anyone on your team is interested in the project, let me know. I'd love either a co-author, or just somebody new to hand off my cobbled together U.S. county/state database to.
Would that be the Pilsner Urquell?
Good work and thank you very much.
Note that Dr. Shahar, your Brownstone reference, is Professor emeritus.
I have noticed this for the 4 1/2 years of the Covid plandemic - the only people who are able to publicly dispute or analyse "The Narrative" are independent of sanction for publicizing their information and conclusions. Cf. Robert Kennedy, Jr. and Steve Kirsch in the USA, both independently wealthy. Numerous victims in Canada such as Dr. Charles Hoffe and Dr. Mark Trozzi have been abused and sanctioned for proposing the truth as they experienced it.
In the "Climate Catastrophe" scam Dr. William Happer and his associates are similarly free of institutional suppression and worth reading.
Very sorry to hear of your continuing illness. Please do what you can to get plenty of sunshine to help yourself heal. God bless you and keep you from harm. Thank you for your work in the service of mankind. Amen.
Thanks. I have been inching nearer to 100%. Lately, I've made my second run this year at getting a consistent bed time in order. Last week it was a drag, but this week I'm getting to sleep between 8 PM and midnight (about to barely make it), and sleeping for 10 hours a day to catch up.
I haven't had anything affect my lungs much in a few months, except I have a slight wheeze from Spring pollen. Pseudafed does the trick.
It may simply be at this point that a year's worth of less exercise, and getting beat up, has my energy level at a lower baseline. But it's getting better.
I think the LED artificial pulsed lighting used at night is not good for you, especially during colder months we are more indoors. Up with the sun and down with the sun puts your body in a much better rhythm and strong state. Get incandescent to read at night.
Trying to subscribe but there's an issue. I will try later.
I believe what I've heard over and over which is that it opens up the cells or signal systems of the body.
I haven’t thought about this in 50 years but when I was a kid one of my school mates told me his great grandmother cured a bout of intestinal parasites by drinking turpentine. It allegedly worked! At the time we all got a good laugh from the story.
If you have a source on this product could you share? I'm interested in all of these old remedies they have used forever until modern medicine of course.
Yes, I am also sorry to hear that you have not fully recovered your health this year. Clean diet, exercise, restorative sleep, and plenty of fresh air and sunshine.
Also I recommend a high-quality (grass-fed beef) collagen supplement in the evening. Works wonders for me.
I don't take many pills, but I do have collagen supplements and take them some evenings.
Great article! I, for one, have always thought vaccinations worked (though I never felt they should be forced). The manipulation of data, immunological omissions and sundry lies during covid have led me (and many others) to seriously question the truthfulness of anything vaccine/drug related. The magnitude of increasingly obvious lies during covid leads me to be significantly more wary of any claims that have been made regarding any vaccine. That doesn't mean vaccines are inherently ineffective or bad but it certainly doesn't mean they arent. And how can we really know when truthful scientific analysis, discussion and constant reevaluation are tantamount to heresy?
I suspect that at least a wide swath of vaccines are just playing pretend, and the authorities know that the data is too difficult to tease apart when you give half a dozen to child at a time. It's criminal.
I never questioned vaccines. Why would I? Each generation since before my grandparents were living longer, infant and child mortality had improved significantly. It sure seemed like the story they were telling made sense.
Seems like pushback started brewing in earnest in the mid 1990s. Stunningly it was the liberals in entertainment and coastal cities that were complaining while conservatives waved them off as whackos.
Given events of late that is some crazy irony, no?
It didn’t hit me until around 2017 they fired high ranking doctor Daniel Neides at the Cleveland Clinic where I worked.
His infraction was merely suggesting we might be better served by questioning the link between autism and childhood vaccinations.
The shitstorm at work and in the media was off the charts. It was insane. Personally I found the reaction highly suspicious.
Here’s the thing as I see it, medicine is a branch of science and science should always be allowed to question. Otherwise what you’ve got ain’t science. It is politics.
Science is by its very nature mercurial. Ever-learning thus changing, adapting and evolving.
Whether I agreed with Dr. Neides questioning of a possible causal link or not was immaterial. Let’s check it out. Let’s do science! But, no.
Shutting him down with major ridicule and loss of employment was over the top. Thus as a result I became way more skeptical of vaccines. And, now? Since Covid. I don’t trust any of them anymore.
Even if the shots were safe as saline and had zero side effects there is enough empirical evidence to show they do not function as advertised.
Yet from where I sit the Covidians remain stubbornly steadfast in their resolve. This is unsurprising to anyone that possesses a basic understanding of human psychology.
Once people openly commit that Coke is better than Pepsi precious few will backtrack. That is why society was panic bludgeoned from the get-go.
It was important to cement vaccine logic into the collective consciousness hard and fast. So they used fear over a phantom menace to do it.
Now, four years later we are stuck with the aftermath. People refusing to see the depth and breadth of a worldwide con. Those professing to see the con focus on personal harms but in reality several million mostly ignored harms and deaths are just a means to an end.
The con was meant to forever change the way we see reality. It shattered Nuremberg, informed consent, personal sovereignty, all rights, bodily, parental, religious, economic, social,personal property. It changed how we perceive government, military and corporate authority.
The con plastered over everything we took for granted and paved the way for the acceptance of authoritarian rule.
The acceptance of authoritarian rule is what Covid was (and still is) all about, Charlie Brown.
Thank you for the final section about making it more simple. I appreciate your work and marvel at the mathematical complexity in your analyses. I am a veterinarian and not a mathematician so I do tend to get lost at times. But, I keep reading!
So long as people move forward with their understanding, that's a win.
I used to feel safe
I used to feel secure
Thinking the world was well functioning
But not anymore
I learned of the thieves
I learned of the crooks
The genocidal dealings
And cooking the books
I learned of the lies
And the notice and leaves
Of papers so cunning
It's hard to believe
I learned of deception
I learned of warfare
I learned that crisis
Is both needed and dear
Because there is no crisis
Without a reaction
Like a chessboard around us
Playing in action
And we are down here
Party to pawns
Castled and cornered
Stunned and scorned
Where evidence points
To fall guys they plant
Trails of evidence
None of us can't
Follow or figure
Just webs of despair
No evidence solid
No politicians care
It's just pockets lined
And divide and command
You think you are free
But living remand
An archaic life
Long thought dismissed
Indentured in servitude
Most ignorant and blissed
Most escaping awareness
Most run away
Thinking it's too hard
Too darkness dismay
And so it continues
It keeps going ‘round
The pieces are taken
Our queen nowhere found
Our bishops are battered
Our knights are all gay
And so it's just us
The pawns left to play
And play
Oh we play with our trinkets
Our distractions and dope
We play because we don't want to hope
We don't want to dare
We don't want to duck
We just want to be left alone
To squander - Fuck
Fuck everyone
Where is your grit
We are losing this battle
We are paddling in shit
Our economy crashing
Our politicians lie
Our hospitals are actually making us die
The food we eat is poisonous crap
Forever chemicals pour from your tap
Attention divided on a ritalin rope
Hanging like a corpse just waiting to choke
If you want to choke
If you want to die
Your children, your friendship
Your husband, your wife
Go out and do it
Don't get in your way
But I'm not hanging myself
Or going out this way
The game isn't over
The game is still on
And I'll go down swinging
Singing this song
Sometimes there is no crisis without a reaction. Sometimes the whole town is burning. The real events make the fake events feel scarier because it takes some time to know the difference when the news cycle starts up.
Sigh.
Very astute
It is that movement of the crowd before the information is available, that is of most concern
Like a boxer throwing a feint
Exposing our ribcage to a thunderous fate
Thanks, Mathew. The clown show was indeed the agenda of the oligarchy. I was fortunate to have begun a deep dive into the history of vaccination and Rockefeller medicine at least a decade before 2020, and having long been a New Yorker subscriber, whose increasingly frequent articles about pandemics and other heebie-jeebies alerted me that something was up, I smelled a psy-op right at the beginning. Helps to be naturally skeptical, too, which, in my case, was thoroughly developed and reinforced through schooling. Mathematics is beautiful (except in California, where it is now woke); it doesn't lie.
My first thought upon reading the headline was “and Matthew Crawford said that about 2 years ago”.
Ahh, the speed of Science™️
One 't' in Mathew. :)
😳
LinkedIn just told me that this article was misinformation Hmmmmmm
Interesting. Please email me a screenshot. I have a specific interest in LinkedIn at the moment.
We don't need any more studies. All vaccines are useless and harmful otherwise we'd be the healthiest country on the planet. After 70 years, we aren't even close.
I hold out the possibility that a subset of vaccines may be successful at the mucosal membrane. Of course, this is less likely for anything injected, and the inclusion of poisons as adjuvants is a big clue that this isn't for our benefit.
Well that is simply not true. They are very effective at killing people. (lolz)
Thank you for the Lets Make This Simpler!
Are we dealing with evil geniuses, talented Mr Ripleys, rogue Gen Rippers, or something else?
The reported finding of "Zero vaccine effectiveness" after looking at all-cause mortality, would tell me that at least these vaccines aren't bad either. However, many countries record excess mortality and are unwilling to share anonymised record-level data to allow people to find the cause of this excess mortality. Meanwhile large increases in cancer and heart-disease have been linked to the Covid-19 vaccines. As far as I understand this analysis, the title should be "Proof of shoddy data analysis by public bodies". Why make out that vaccine effectiveness is zero because very likely it's negative?
I've pondered this, and I think that after accounting for healthy user bias for vaccines, we must also account for increases in drug and alcohol deaths, which have an unhealthy user bias, and tilt back the other direction. I do think that my original calculations that I did in mid-2021 are still likely correct---particularly since they were spot on with the German health insurer's 400k interviews.
Here is a paper from the same journal that would suggest things are worse than "zero effectiveness" : https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0264410X24001270?via%3Dihub#s0090
But conclusions are based on data that is itself nonsensical, as in showing that Covid-19 vaccine seems to help prevent traffic-accident deaths, for example. I think in the present circumstances, with a paucity of reliable data, it's too bold to state there is "Zero Vaccine Effectiveness". We don't know that yet, because likely there is Negative vaccine effectiveness. And that means it doesn't really make sense to look at all cause mortality and talk about vaccine effectiveness. We still don't know whether the vaccine prevented some Covid-19 illness which was offset by people dying from a heart attack due to vaccination.
I could say all this is fine and dandy, job well done, cudos, and any other commendation. In fact, it is piddling about, which also involves HUB, HVE, UVE, ZVEH, and all the other monstrous academic constructs. What good is it analyzing whether the poison death shot (TM@Dr. Zelenko, RIP) works or not, while maintaining the gross fiction of a "vaccine", or even "pandemic"? It is as if scholastics came back, with their multitude of angels dancing on the point of a needle.
Dr. Trozzi, for one, cuts to the chase; just listen to him for more than five minutes: https://drtrozzi.substack.com/p/wins-of-the-week-ep17-with-ted-kuntz
As for Karl Rove, he must be rolling over with laughter on his sofa. "We’re an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you’re studying that reality — judiciously, as you will — we’ll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that’s how things will sort out. We’re history’s actors . . . and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do.” Indeed - studying, check; judiciously, check; you, all of you; really wanna be a part of the set that proves Rove right?
I gave the lay of the land elsewhere, and the older it gets, the more valid it seems. https://open.substack.com/pub/lionessofjudah/p/dr-michael-yeadon-this-must-stop?r=z8hkl&utm_campaign=comment-list-share-cta&utm_medium=web&comments=true&commentId=4813798
It is not about what the injectable poisonous LNP slops do not do; it is about what they do do, because by their fruits ye shall know them. The fruits are the same everywhere, and statistically if you wish, come in the shape of excess mortality. The current Protectorate of Boehmen u. Maehren recorded excess mortality of 7.5% in 2022, and 10.1% in 2023. Occam´s razor is the only thing that Mr. Furst need apply here. Morbidity and disability would be the other tracks to follow, together with ancillary data like waiting times for being seen by a neurologist (10 months) or psychiatrist (4 months). Just those two specialties would give some indication of what is up, and Slide 16 provides the reasons why.
"What good is it to write any article other than the one that I would have written talking about other things? Karl Rove knows that writing about anything is useless."
It was very interesting to see how intensely people embraced the idea that if you took the shot you were great and you did everything. If you didn't take it ,you were a granny killing piece of crap who did nothing .At no point did the idea get brought up that the best way to approach the mucosal immune system is through the nose and mouth, not an injection. Vitamin d levels, nasal sprays, zinc etc. were considered anti vaxx before the shots even came out. Many useful pieces of information emerged, When Hydroxy and ivermectin were cut off, people realized that quercetin could get the zinc into the cells. Vitamin d levels above 50nm seems to be the biggest key. I firmly believe that three pairings of nutrients should be promoted for optimal illness protection at minimal expense. 1-vitamin d3 and vitamin k2. 2-magnesium and vitamin c. 3-zinc and quercetin(or black seed oil). I take this combo every day and rarely catch anything. All of these are important and in combination they bring out the full potential of the vitamin d and zinc. That is the large study I would like to see. People taking proper amounts of those six nutrients every day vs. all the flu and covid shots.
Very interesting – county doctors vs city doctors. I agree it is the tricksters (large international corporations & evil ones) who are creating a toxic world (vaccines, other drugs, environment, and much more) but also their brainwashing and control of the media, government… is amazing.